Dennis Kneale

  • Home
  • What’s Bugging Me
  • Dennis Kneale Media
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Obama in Stem Cell Straits

August 24, 2010 By Dennis Kneale

President Obama faces a messy political fight over the federal court ruling striking down his new, looser policy letting federal grant money pay for stem cell research involving “destroyed” embryos.

Obama - Dennis Kneale

Flickr: Some rights reserved. joecrimmings

Obama hands a juicy moral issue to the Republicans if he does the right thing and pushes for Congress to rewrite a 1996 law banning federal funds for embryonic research—the key factor cited in the federal court ruling yesterday. It would distract from the legislative achievements he trumpets (dubious though they are: ObamaCare and fin-reg reform).

But if Obama stands down and lets this judicial slap go unanswered, he abandons the issue to the crazies on the far Right. This would hurt the US in scientific competitiveness, hobble drugmakers in pursuing the next wave of innovation and sentence millions of patients to languish and without hope that science might save them.

Our President had promised to Change that bleak picture.

While Congress had first acted in 1996, a farther-reaching ban came after President George W. Bush took office in 2001. The almost decade-long Bush ban on stem cell research was a lamentable and patently political act, sacrificing great scientific promise to hack ideological expediency.

Worse, it was wrongheaded. Pushed by anti-abortion forces, it aimed at the wrong target—research on embryos as opposed to research on cells from actual fetuses from abortions. One scientist in the field told me that federally funded research involving aborted fetal cells continued unhindered, but grants were banned for any experiments involving embryos that had nothing to do with abortions.

The almost decade-long Bush ban has dealt a blow to US med-tech companies. Britain is a teeming center of stem cell work. In the US, university labs were forced to set up redundant, sequestered operations to ensure that no federal money seeped into the forbidden science.

And for what?

The sanctity of life at the moment of inception in the womb and all that—I know, I know. Even a supporter of pro-choice rights for women (as I am) might balk at the thought of thousands of embryos being “harvested” from women otherwise headed for abortions, so these eggs could then line laboratory petri dishes across the country for all manner of strange experiments.

But let’s put it in perspective: How many embryos are we really talking about here? We aren’t talking thousands at all: we’re talking maybe dozens.

A few years ago, I visited a stem-cell lab at University College London, where some 110 research teams were conducting ongoing projects in stem cell research. When pro-lifers staged a protest rally a few months earlier, crusaders demanded to know: Just how many embryos did researchers kill to supply those 110 teams of scientists?

Answer: Five.

Just five eggs were “destroyed,” but it was enough to supply over a hundred research projects because of cellular replication (and you thought you’d never need to know what you failed to grasp in biology class in the tenth grade).

Most of the needed embryos could come from the in-vitro leftovers of infertile women who later were able to conceive, frozen fertilized eggs that weren’t going to be used, anyway.

The inconsequential numbers won’t stop the far Right from igniting a political firefight, yet again, over the issue of stem cell research. My hope, though, is that it might embolden Bam and the pro-choice Left to push back at the anti-science Luddites. It might give pause even to moderate Republicans who prefer to avoid this moral grandstanding.

Just keeping thinking the real scale of this: Five eggs for over a hundred research teams. Just five.

Filed Under: Featured, Top Story

Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale covers media & tech, healthcare & science, business vs. government and other pursuits in the realm where creative destruction collides with wealth creation.
  • View All Posts
Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale
25-year inkstained wretch (WSJ, Forbes) goes TV: ex-CNBC, ex-Fox. Here's the bio...

Sign Up for Email Alerts

Latest Tweets

  • The blockchain gave it away!!! @SpecialSitsNews https://t.co/64FF51fdW1 26 minutes ago
  • And the lapdog media are IGNORING IT. #ShamelessShills @TomFitton https://t.co/9bBV11AeAk 27 minutes ago
  • This is an outrage. We need to stop filming and start intervening, if everyone does it, the thugs and criminals wil… https://t.co/zv1FK65MxT 28 minutes ago
  • Shot… chaser. Fed unwisely RAISES rates yesterday… and the free market then sends rates DOWN in bond trading. Telli… https://t.co/jJgdLfzcFO 31 minutes ago
  • Biden got outflanked, it is embarrassing. https://t.co/VbYale6yuF 52 minutes ago
  • Because libs are afraid to listen… and learn how lame their arguments really are, JimmyI! @jimiuorio https://t.co/8UYEJHi6Db 54 minutes ago
  • So desperate. https://t.co/5VZlYVVNPe 56 minutes ago
  • ABL my comment invokes the Trump nickname to make fun of a sanctimonious, bank-bashing pol for falsely claiming an… https://t.co/pqz0onwbSp About 11 hours ago
  • As @carney and @loudobbs would recall, when @realDonaldTrump dared criticize the Fed, it was decried as an historic… https://t.co/SwKKdIxius About 13 hours ago
  • Mmm what is a liberal? @jimiuorio https://t.co/fdFCLwxja9 Yesterday at 11:18 pm
  • “Dangerous” how, exactly? https://t.co/13WUMWKtzd Yesterday at 8:40 pm
  • And this is why a grand jury can be talked into indicting a ham sandwich, if that is what the prosecutor wants. https://t.co/5qjqgP3cJI Yesterday at 8:39 pm
  • Oh man! I wanna do this blessed beef event in person. https://t.co/WBh18zUQHq Yesterday at 8:37 pm
  • Yup, yet Stanford’s Virality Platform helped Twitter, Facebook/Instagram, Google/YouTube, et al censor accurate, tr… https://t.co/98b93noZsE Yesterday at 8:36 pm
  • Streetbites. One moment you are on the M train ensconced in darkness of the subway tunnel… and next you are high in… https://t.co/lATCRghvUI Yesterday at 8:34 pm

Copyright © 2023 Dennis Kneale