Dennis Kneale

  • Home
  • What’s Bugging Me
  • Dennis Kneale Media
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

The Comcast-Netflix Equation

March 24, 2014 By Dennis Kneale

comcast netflix artPart 2.  See also Part 1: Comcast’s Bite at the Apple http://denniskneale.com/comcasts-bite-at-the-apple/347

A deal between Apple and Comcast would be a huge advance for Net-TV, streaming live and on-demand video from a new Apple set-top device plugged directly into Comcast cable systems.  But it would be bad for Netflix.  And it also could hasten the erosion of a far bigger business at Comcast—cable-TV, in which fat packages of dozens of channels afford high profit margins and mask barely detectable price increases and any link between usage and pricing.

Comcast will dominate the U.S. cable business with 30 million subscriber homes after it acquires #2 Time Warner Cable (presumably).  It isn’t withering under the Internet-threat, it’s thriving, helped in part by the Internet-access business.   So why hasten the day when Internet streaming and al a carte might replace the tiered channel packages that now prop up profits in the cable business?  (And Comcast, in this instance, owns more of both sides of the house than most any other company in the world).

Okay sure:  maybe Comcast should do it because, if it’s inevitable, it’s better to pre-empt yourself rather than have it done to you.  But you can give in too early.  As AOL did some years ago when it embraced the “free” Internet and scrapped a declining subscriber business that still had more than 10 million people paying $20 or so a month.

And this next Internet wave is harder than those before it.  Right now 30 million of the nation’s 110 million homes stream on Netflix.  Netflix and YouTube together hog half of the nation’s nightly bandwidth.  But one day when most everyone is streaming something, big snarls and snags and traffic jams will erupt.

Two weeks ago, HBO Go, the innovative watch-anywhere streaming service from the Time Warner-owned channel, crashed under a rush of “live” viewers of the season finale for the much-hailed “True Detective.”  This, after ABC had similar problems streaming the Oscars.

We Americans have become tolerant of tech’s flaws and foibles—but mess with our ability to watch TV, and we will get ugly.

This is why Netflix, after whining about cable providers’ ability to raise prices for carrying its horde of online movies and TV shows, now deigns to pay Comcast extra for priority video service; and why Apple now is in talks to do the same.

Which leads to the threat to Netflix posed by the talks between Apple and Comcast, reported this morning in The Wall Street Journal.  A few weeks ago, Netflix’s move to ally with Comcast looked like a coup.  But now Apple suddenly could slide into a deal with Comcast, too, and Amazon and Hulu can’t be far behind.  So much for any first-mover advantage to Netflix.

And if Apple gets serious about a new streaming service, Netflix would have the most to lose.  Apple has $40 billion in cash and investments on hand; Netflix has just $1.2B.  Apple’s market value is at $480 billion even after a long fall to $536 now from $700 a share in September 2012; Netflix’s value is at all of $22B.

In fact, maybe Apple should just buy Netflix outright.

NFLX has done a great job pushing its customers to drop old, cumbersome DVDs and switch to streaming on the Internet.  But Netflix stock more than tripled in 2013, and Apple need not buy it at these lofty prices.   Instead, Apple could wait and rev up a new AppleTV streaming service, with Comcast offering it instantly in 30 million homes.  Netflix has little room for error: On $1.18 billion in revenue last quarter, it held on to only $5 million in free cash.

Give it a few years, and Apple one day may be able to buy Netflix on the cheap.

Filed Under: Top Story

Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale covers media & tech, healthcare & science, business vs. government and other pursuits in the realm where creative destruction collides with wealth creation.
  • View All Posts
Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale
25-year inkstained wretch (WSJ, Forbes) goes TV: ex-CNBC, ex-Fox. Here's the bio...

Sign Up for Email Alerts

Latest Tweets

  • Nope. No way. https://t.co/6Czh9Y4ldj About 6 hours ago
  • Seconded. #WhatsBuggingMe on @Ricochet https://t.co/wm88DyB5AZ About 7 hours ago
  • Up now @NEWSMAX #WhatsBuggingMe my column on Trump's out-of-line attack on Kayleigh McEnany. When will he learn to… https://t.co/T7lVFiKhe1 Yesterday at 9:20 pm
  • Good, memorized bit… and then @DRUDGE sold out and had a brain transplant to turn liberal msm. https://t.co/mzTutkAHDo Yesterday at 5:20 pm
  • Cue next anti-Trump meme: RINO Repubs solemnly bowing out of a race they had no chance of winning, because Trump Ba… https://t.co/y9ResW86ow Yesterday at 5:17 pm
  • Everything ends up being about @realDonaldTrump. #WhatsBuggingMe on @Ricochet https://t.co/DczyNuafDj Yesterday at 4:47 pm
  • Drill drill drill. https://t.co/BsDFt9aaxn Yesterday at 3:53 pm
  • Set afire by the blaze he himself started? Seem to recall his shining a harsh spotight on FTX scam, or was that som… https://t.co/JCowhBbCxd Yesterday at 3:49 pm
  • We yearn for the return of Reagan’s 11th Commandment: Thou shalt not attack a fellow Republican. #WhatsBuggingMe o… https://t.co/Hic6XBGW9w Yesterday at 3:45 pm
  • Gee I Wonder Why Dept. #WhatsBuggingMe on @Ricochet https://t.co/IZLdoueKzZ Yesterday at 3:41 pm
  • Ouch: the great @marklevinshow takes aim at Chris Christie moments before CC’s likely announcement of a low-odds ru… https://t.co/JArww5qYQm Yesterday at 3:40 pm
  • 🤣🤣🤣🤣 https://t.co/yGMF9Wj1uC June 5, 2023 12:20 am
  • OMG!!!! Media? Media? Bueller? #WhatsBuggingMe on @Ricochet https://t.co/wSC85T8Ju7 June 4, 2023 5:34 pm
  • At yheaters now: The Karate Kitty. Wax on. Wax off. Wax on. Wax off. https://t.co/5ZEIXmgc7n June 4, 2023 5:32 pm
  • Sure was, thanks to the Borellis the both of em?! @deneenborelli and @tomborelli #WhatsBuggingMe on @Ricochet https://t.co/Wi0lC779On June 4, 2023 4:30 pm

Copyright © 2023 Dennis Kneale