Dennis Kneale

  • Home
  • What’s Bugging Me
  • Dennis Kneale Media
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Surfing the Next Wave, Part 3

May 7, 2014 By Dennis Kneale

Vivek Blog art2And now to bring it all home…

THEME #4: What’s an Incumbent to Do?

Steve Case speaks from experience: “The mistake is not that companies don’t have a sense of where the world is going,” he says, “it’s that they don’t put enough resources against that initiative and the best people against that initiative.”

He cites the Powell Doctrine of attacking with overwhelming force, from Gen. Colin Powell, who was on the board of the old (and faltering) AOL Time Warner and just joined the board of Salesforce.com.

“If you attack, attack and play to win,” Case advises. “Big companies dabble all too often. It has to be a focused, energetic, resource-intensive battle that’s worth fighting, and you fight that battle to prevail, not just have some people doing something around the fringes.”

Benioff seconds that sentiment: “That’s why very, very few companies in the history of our industry have ever been able to do that successfully.”

Google and Facebook are striking in their willingness to go full-force. “When they identify a problem or opportunity, they attack it with vigor,” Case says. Wadhwa concurs, in part: “The one company that keeps acting like its life is in danger is Google.”  Led by Larry Page, Google invests in new-tech for driverless cars, robotics, drones, airborne wireless routers and more . . . never mind that 95% of its revenue comes from advertising.

And what of Salesforce.com? Vivek Wadhwa, asked whether the company’s stock is a “sell” given the threat of the Third Wave, says he would move Benioff from CEO to CTO—chief technology officer.

I respond: “But the thing is, when you’re a total control freak, you’re not really gonna do that. What do you say, Mark?”

“I think I’ve done alright as CEO,” Benioff says. “I think my results speak for themselves.”

Wadhwa: “But you’re the incumbent now, that’s what the problem is. You don’t have control over the rest of the company.”

Benioff: “No, I think that you underestimate the importance of being the CEO of a tech company.” Steve Case could speak to this point, too, he says. “You have to be the leader, you have to take responsibility for the operational and visionary aspects. You have to have the ability to do both. That’s what a technology CEO does.”

Marc is on a roll now: “And you can’t say somebody else is going to do vision. That’s why CEOs fail. CEOs fail if they execute what you just said: ‘Oh, I’m going to delegate innovation, I’m going to delegate that moonshot.’”

Yet he allows that most incumbents fail at all this. Steve Case sounds a warning: “Silicon Valley is awesome, it’s the pride of America and the envy of the world. I think it is awesome. (But) sixty years ago, Detroit was Silicon Valley,” he says. “It lost its entrepreneurial mojo.”

Vivek Wadhwa says we make the mistake of assuming the U.S. has a monopoly on innovation. “It doesn’t. The same advances that are happening here are happening everywhere. The same sensors that Mark talked about are now available everywhere. The entrepreneurship that Steve talked about is happening everywhere.”

I counter: “Then why are you saying that the next revolution will benefit the U.S. more than it benefits everywhere else?”  Wadhwa rattles off a litany of upsides that should make investors roar:

“Because it’s bringing manufacturing back to us.   We’re now becoming self-sufficient in energy. We’re now going to have solar energy driving us. We benefit because it’s emanating from here, and ultimately we become more independent and we rise faster. We’re able to innovate faster than any other country is.”

And the dismount: “Despite the fact that we’re dumb in immigration,” says Wadhwa, “the fact is that people still want to come here, because the networks are here, the money is here, the power is here, the ability to distribute, to make things happen, is here.”

“The magic happens in America, still.”

____________________________

See also: Surfing the Wave, Part 1:  http://bit.ly/1mDat2p

Part 2:  Incumbents vs. Upstarts:  http://bit.ly/1mDa2Fm

Click here for video of the full panel on Internet destruction: http://bit.ly/1j2UdiR

Filed Under: Featured

Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale covers media & tech, healthcare & science, business vs. government and other pursuits in the realm where creative destruction collides with wealth creation.
  • View All Posts
Dennis Kneale

Dennis Kneale
25-year inkstained wretch (WSJ, Forbes) goes TV: ex-CNBC, ex-Fox. Here's the bio...

Sign Up for Email Alerts

Latest Tweets

  • Witty of you, and what I said was accurate and true about a federal court order forcing separation of kids & adults… https://t.co/6vwp0ueCNy About 3 hours ago
  • Just finished my 445th workout on the great @8fit app. First meal of the day up now. #BreakfastofChampions https://t.co/59DyYlrrSF About 3 hours ago
  • Well summarized and succinctly put. https://t.co/azfh0c9Gwr About 4 hours ago
  • Trenchant observation. @McKaylaRoseJ https://t.co/Ja6yxBXisN About 5 hours ago
  • It is a rather stunning admission by the @Demwits that they doubt the mental comoetency of their “President.”… https://t.co/Y7mGuVopyv About 5 hours ago
  • So stupid. If you are that fearful, cancel the class. https://t.co/cB0uA7Wrjf About 5 hours ago
  • Searing. https://t.co/gm6z51I318 About 5 hours ago
  • Because someone authorized it. https://t.co/cjwINw0oCy About 5 hours ago
  • That is entirely, factually wrong, thanks to slipshod media coverage. In FACT, a federal judge’s order required sep… https://t.co/5nDkDdY1Va About 7 hours ago
  • Way too true. @megynkelly https://t.co/RWkhQ44Ef4 About 17 hours ago
  • “I’ll bet you do, sweet thing.” https://t.co/i2nwBKikA2 About 19 hours ago
  • Tge Times is a national embarrassment even to its own subscribers. Freshmen liberalism at its finest. https://t.co/WnFdOlJ59K Yesterday at 10:39 pm
  • Whoops, sorry about that. The driver stayed a gentleman, good on him. https://t.co/cpszBlYaEP February 24, 2021 9:37 pm
  • Searing and stinging. https://t.co/gT052icrih February 24, 2021 7:10 pm
  • Where is this all coming from? And who controls it? A month ago Cuomo was adored by #Demwits & media as presidentia… https://t.co/DWD4xoc24y February 24, 2021 7:09 pm

Copyright © 2021 Dennis Kneale